Difference between revisions of "Employment Law Issues (9:V)"

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 857: Line 857:
This prohibition against discrimination in employment includes discrimination in the hiring process, in the terms and conditions of employment,  and in decisions to terminate employment. Employment agencies also must not refuse to refer a person for employment based on one of the prohibited grounds for discrimination. Trade unions, employer’s organizations, and occupational associations cannot discriminate against people by excluding, expelling or suspending them from membership (s 14).
This prohibition against discrimination in employment includes discrimination in the hiring process, in the terms and conditions of employment,  and in decisions to terminate employment. Employment agencies also must not refuse to refer a person for employment based on one of the prohibited grounds for discrimination. Trade unions, employer’s organizations, and occupational associations cannot discriminate against people by excluding, expelling or suspending them from membership (s 14).


There must be no discrimination in wages paid (s 12). Men and women must receive equal pay for similar or substantially similar work.  Similarity is to be determined having regard to the skill, effort, and responsibility required by a job. Family status protection includes childcare and family obligations. See ''Johnstone v Canada Border Services'' (2010 CHRT 20).  
There must be no discrimination in wages paid (s 12). Men and women must receive equal pay for similar or substantially similar work.  Similarity is to be determined having regard to the skill, effort, and responsibility required by a job.  
 
Family status protection includes childcare and family obligations. See ''Johnstone v Canada Border Services'' (2010 CHRT 20).  


For more information about each of the prohibited grounds, see [[BC Human Rights Code (6:III)#B. Prohibited Grounds of Discrimination | Chapter 6: Human Rights, Section III.B: Prohibited Grounds of Discrimination]]. See also “Recent Human Rights Cases of Interest for Employment Lawyers”, Michael A. Watt, Employment Law Conference 2014, Paper 4.1, CLE BC.   
For more information about each of the prohibited grounds, see [[BC Human Rights Code (6:III)#B. Prohibited Grounds of Discrimination | Chapter 6: Human Rights, Section III.B: Prohibited Grounds of Discrimination]]. See also “Recent Human Rights Cases of Interest for Employment Lawyers”, Michael A. Watt, Employment Law Conference 2014, Paper 4.1, CLE BC.   
Line 869: Line 871:
Similar protections are provided to that of the ''Human Rights Code'', though they are not identical.  
Similar protections are provided to that of the ''Human Rights Code'', though they are not identical.  


The federal act allows employers to have mandatory retirement, whereas in BC, the provincial code was amended in 2008 to prohibit mandatory retirement.
Federal legislation allows employers to impose manadatory retirement, however, the BC provincial statute was amended in 2008 to prohibit this practice


Federal equal pay provisions in the ''Canadian Human Rights Act'' are somewhat broader than those found in B.C.’s ''Human Rights Code''. It is discriminatory under the ''Canadian Human Rights Act'' to pay male and female employees different wages where the work that they are doing is of comparatively equal value. This means that even if the work itself is not demonstrably similar, the pay equity provisions may still be enforced if the value of the work is similar. Factors that are considered in determining whether work is of equal value include: skill, efforts and responsibility required, and conditions under which the work is performed (''Canadian Human Rights Act'', s 11(2)).
Federal equal pay provisions in the ''Canadian Human Rights Act'' are somewhat broader than those found in B.C.’s ''Human Rights Code''. It is discriminatory under the ''Canadian Human Rights Act'' to pay male and female employees different wages where the work that they are doing is of comparatively equal value. This means that even if the work itself is not demonstrably similar, the pay equity provisions may still be enforced if the value of the work is similar. Factors that are considered in determining whether work is of equal value include: skill, efforts and responsibility required, and conditions under which the work is performed (''Canadian Human Rights Act'', s 11(2)).
Line 891: Line 893:
==== a) Employment Standards Act ====
==== a) Employment Standards Act ====


An employer may not threaten, terminate, suspend, discipline, penalize, intimidate, or coerce an employee because the employee filed a complaint under the ''ESA'' (s 83). If this does happen, the Employment Standards Branch may order that the employer comply with the section,  cease doing the act, pay reasonable expenses, hire or reinstate the employee and pay lost wages, or pay compensation (s 79). A complaint may be filed with the Employment Standards Branch  
An employer may not threaten, terminate, suspend, discipline, penalize, intimidate, or coerce an employee because the employee filed a complaint under the ''ESA'' (s 83). If this does happen, the Employment Standards Branch may order that the employer comply with the section,  cease doing the act, pay reasonable expenses, hire or reinstate the employee and pay lost wages, or pay compensation (s 79). A complaint may be filed with the Employment Standards Branch.


==== b) Human Rights Code ====
==== b) Human Rights Code ====
Line 927: Line 929:
Complaints regarding a breach of ''FOIPPA'' or ''PIPA'' can be filed with the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner for British Columbia.  
Complaints regarding a breach of ''FOIPPA'' or ''PIPA'' can be filed with the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner for British Columbia.  


=== 4. Termination ===
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice recognized the tort of public disclosure of private facts in ''Doe v. D'', 2016 ONSC 541, so there may be a new common law remedy in the appropriate circumstances.  
 
One of the most frequent issues students will have to address is to advise an employee of his entitlements following termination of employment. See [[{{PAGENAME}}#D. Termination of Employment | IV.D: Termination of Employment]] below.
 
=== 5. Failure to Comply with Statutory Requirements ===
 
Employees often have complaints that their employers is not providing them with their statutory entitlements under the ''Employment Standards Act'', such as a failure to pay overtime wages or vacation pay. See [[{{PAGENAME}}#C. Employment Standards Entitlements | IV.C. Employment Standards Entitlements]] for a discussion on this topic.
 


{{LSLAP Manual Navbox|type=chapters8-14}}
{{LSLAP Manual Navbox|type=chapters8-14}}