Difference between revisions of "Introduction to Family Law in British Columbia"

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 3: Line 3:
|resourcetype = more fact sheets, publications, and videos on  
|resourcetype = more fact sheets, publications, and videos on  
|link        = [http://www.familylaw.lss.bc.ca/legal_issues/legalSystemBasics.php Legal System Basics]
|link        = [http://www.familylaw.lss.bc.ca/legal_issues/legalSystemBasics.php Legal System Basics]
}}This section offers a short introduction to the principles of family law in British Columbia and the ways that family law problems are resolved. It's written in easy-to-understand language and is meant for people who have never had to deal with the legal system before and for people who are new to Canada.
}}This section offers a short introduction to family law in British Columbia and the ways that family law problems are resolved. It's written in easy-to-understand language and is meant for people who have never had to deal with the legal system before and for people who are new to Canada.


This section is meant to be read as a whole, from start to finish. The main chapters of this wikibook go into each subject in a lot more detail. When you're done with this section, the chapter [[Introduction to the Legal System for Family Matters|The Legal System]] has a more complete introduction to family law and dispute resolution processes in BC.
This section is meant to be read as a whole, from start to finish. The main chapters of this wikibook go into each subject in a lot more detail. When you're done with this section, the chapter [[Introduction to the Legal System for Family Matters|The Legal System]] has a more complete introduction to family law and dispute resolution in BC.


Here you will find an overview of common family law problems, the laws that deal with family law problems, the courts that deal with family law problems, and the other ways that family law problems are resolved. This section talks briefly about the law on the care of children, child support, spousal support, the division of property and debt, separation and divorce, and family law agreements.
Here you will find an overview of common family law problems, the laws that deal with family law problems, the courts that deal with family law problems, and the other ways that family law problems are resolved. This section talks briefly about the law on the care of children, child support, spousal support, how property and debts are shared, separation and divorce, and family law agreements.


==Introduction==
==Introduction==
Line 13: Line 13:
When a couple breaks up, they may have to decide how a child <span class="noglossary">will</span> be cared for, how property should be divided, and whether someone needs extra money to help pay the bills. Family law, sometimes also called divorce law or the law on domestic relations, is the area of the law that deals with problems like these.
When a couple breaks up, they may have to decide how a child <span class="noglossary">will</span> be cared for, how property should be divided, and whether someone needs extra money to help pay the bills. Family law, sometimes also called divorce law or the law on domestic relations, is the area of the law that deals with problems like these.


To understand how family law works in British Columbia, you need to have a basic understanding of the legal system, the laws about family law problems, and how the courts apply those laws when a couple can't agree about something. Since it isn't always necessary to go to court when there's a problem, you also need to know about negotiation and mediation. These are the most common ways that people solve their problems without the help of a judge.
To understand how family law works in British Columbia, you need to have a basic understanding of the legal system, the law about family law problems, and how the courts apply the law when a couple can't agree about something. Since it isn't always necessary to go to court when there's a problem, you also need to know about negotiation, mediation and arbitration. These are other ways that people can solve their problems without going to see a judge.


Family law problems are resolved in one of two ways:  
Family law problems are resolved in one of two ways:  
#the couple bargain with each other and come up with a solution that they both agree to; or,  
#the couple bargain with each other and come up with a solution that they both agree to; or,  
#the couple can't agree and they have to ask someone else to come up with a solution, usually by going to court.  
#the couple can't agree and they have to ask someone else to come up with a solution, usually by going to court or to an arbitrator.  


Going to court means that one or both people have or will start a court proceeding. (Court proceedings are also known as ''lawsuits'', ''claims'' or ''actions''.) Going to court is called ''litigation''; trying to come up with an agreement without going to court is called ''negotiation''. Mediation is a kind of negotiation.
Going to court means that one or both people have or will start a court proceeding. (Court proceedings are also known as ''lawsuits'', ''claims'' or ''actions''.) Going to court is called ''litigation''; trying to come up with an agreement without going to court is called ''negotiation''. Mediation is a kind of negotiation. Arbitration is like going to a private court where you get to pick the judge.


There are two courts that handle almost all family law litigation in British Columbia: the Provincial (Family) Court and the Supreme Court. Each court has its own rules, its own forms, and its own process.
There are two courts that handle almost all family law litigation in British Columbia: the Provincial (Family) Court and the Supreme Court. Each court has its own rules, its own forms, and its own process.


There are two main laws that apply to family law problems. A law, in this sense of the word, means a rule made by the government. These laws are the federal ''[[Divorce Act]]'' and the provincial ''[[Family Law Act]]''. Each law deals with different issues, although they share a lot of issues in common. For some couples, both laws <span class="noglossary">will</span> apply; for others, only one of these laws <span class="noglossary">will</span> apply, probably the ''[[Family Law Act]]''.
There are two main laws that apply to family law problems. A law, in this sense of the word, means a rule made by the government. (This kind of law is also called ''legislation'' or ''statute law''.) These laws are the ''[[Divorce Act]]'', made by the federal government, and the ''[[Family Law Act]]'', made by the provincial government. Although the laws cover some of the same legal issues, each law also covers issues that the other doesn't. For some couples, both laws <span class="noglossary">will</span> apply; for others, only one of these laws <span class="noglossary">will</span> apply, probably the ''[[Family Law Act]]''.


It's important to know that you don't have to go to court, no matter how bad your problem is. The only times you ''must'' go to court are when:
It's important to know that you don't have to go to court, no matter how bad your problem is. The only times you ''must'' go to court are when:
Line 29: Line 29:
*you need a divorce,  
*you need a divorce,  
*someone is threatening to do something serious, like take the children away,
*someone is threatening to do something serious, like take the children away,
*there is a risk of violence,
*there is a risk of violence, or
*someone is threatening to hide property or money, or
*someone is threatening to hide, sell or give away property or money.
*you just can't agree about how to solve the problem no matter how hard you try.


If you don't have to deal with one or more of these issues, you can always try to negotiate a way of fixing the problem, to find a solution that you both agree with. Couples who need help negotiating sometimes hire someone else to help, someone who has special training helping people resolve problems and make deals, called a ''mediator''. Mediators help to guide the negotiation process and encourage people to see different ways of solving the problem.
If you don't have to deal with one or more of these issues, you can always try to negotiate a way of fixing the problem, to find a solution that you both agree with. Couples who need help negotiating sometimes hire someone else to help, someone who has special training helping people resolve problems and make deals, called a ''mediator''. Mediators help to guide the negotiation process and encourage people to see different ways of solving the problem. Arbitration is an alternative to court when you host can't reach an agreement no matter how hard you try.


Lawyers who mediate family law problems are called ''family law mediators'', and have additional training in mediation apart from their training as lawyers. Because there are no rules about who can and who can't call themselves a mediator, you should look carefully at a mediator's credentials before you agree to use that person as your mediator.
Lawyers who mediate family law problems are called ''family law mediators'', and have additional training in mediation apart from their training as lawyers. Because there are no rules about who can and who can't call themselves a mediator, you should look carefully at a mediator's credentials before you agree to use that person as your mediator. In the same way, lawyers who arbitrate family law problems are called ''family law arbitrators'', and have additional training in arbitration apart from their training as lawyers. Because there are no rules about who can and who can't call themselves a mediator or an arbitrator, you should look carefully at the mediator's or arbitrator's credentials before you agree to use that person as your mediator or arbitrator.


'''Further reading:'''
'''Further reading:'''
Line 45: Line 44:
==Common family law problems==
==Common family law problems==


All sorts of people in all sorts of situations can have family law problems, including couples who live together and couples who don't, couples who are married and couples who aren't, and couples who intended to have a child together and couples who didn't. In British Columbia, family law applies to same sex couples in exactly the same way that it applies to opposite-sex couples. The sorts of problems a couple can have when their relationship ends include deciding how the children <span class="noglossary">will</span> be cared for, whether support should be paid, and who <span class="noglossary">will</span> keep which property and which debt.
All sorts of people in all sorts of situations can have family law problems, including couples who live together and couples who don't, couples who are married to each other and couples who aren't, and couples who intended to have a child together and couples who didn't. In British Columbia, family law applies to same sex couples in exactly the same way that it applies to opposite-sex couples. Family law also applies when the family isn't a couple but includes more than two adults.
 
The sorts of problems adults can have when their relationship ends include deciding how the children <span class="noglossary">will</span> be cared for, whether support should be paid, and who <span class="noglossary">will</span> keep which property and which debt.


Family law problems about children include making decisions about:
Family law problems about children include making decisions about:
Line 51: Line 52:
*''parenting time'' or ''custody'', which includes deciding where the children <span class="noglossary">will</span> live for most of the time,  
*''parenting time'' or ''custody'', which includes deciding where the children <span class="noglossary">will</span> live for most of the time,  
*''parental responsibilities'' or ''custody'', which includes deciding how parents or guardians <span class="noglossary">will</span> make decisions about important things in the children's lives, about issues like health care and education, and
*''parental responsibilities'' or ''custody'', which includes deciding how parents or guardians <span class="noglossary">will</span> make decisions about important things in the children's lives, about issues like health care and education, and
*''parenting time'', ''contact'' or ''access'', which are about deciding how much time each parent and other people <span class="noglossary">will</span> have with the children.
*''parenting time'', ''contact'' or ''access'', which are about deciding how much time each parent and sometimes other people <span class="noglossary">will</span> have with the children.


Support means money that one person pays another to help with that person's expenses. Family law problems about support include:
Support means money that one person pays another to help with that person's expenses. Family law problems about support include:


*''child support'', money that is paid to help with expenses for the children, like shelter, clothing, medical expenses and food, and
*''child support'', money that is paid to help with expenses for the children, like shelter, clothing, medical expenses and food, and
*''spousal support'', money that is paid to help with a spouse's day-to-day living expenses, like rent, the phone bill and the hydro <span class="noglossary">bill</span>, and sometimes money that is paid to compensate a spouse for effect of economic decisions made during the relationship.
*''spousal support'', money that is paid to help with a spouse's day-to-day living expenses, like rent, the phone bill and the electricity <span class="noglossary">bill</span>, and sometimes money that is paid to compensate a spouse for effect of decisions about work and money made during the relationship.


When a couple have property, sometimes including when only one person has property, they have to decide if and how that property <span class="noglossary">will</span> be shared between them. In family law, the property married spouses and unmarried spouses share is called ''family property'', generally only the property that accumulated during a relationship. Family property can include things like houses, bank accounts, and cars. It can also include RRSPs and pensions. Sometimes a couple also has to decide who <span class="noglossary">will</span> take responsibility for debts. Generally, only the debts that accumulated during a relationship <span class="noglossary">will</span> be shared between married spouses and unmarried spouses.
When a couple have property, sometimes including when only one person has property, they have to decide if and how that property <span class="noglossary">will</span> be shared between them. In family law, the property married spouses and unmarried spouses share is called ''family property'', generally only the property that accumulated during a relationship. Family property can include things like houses, bank accounts, businesses and cars. It can also include RRSPs and pensions. Sometimes a couple also has to decide who <span class="noglossary">will</span> take responsibility for debts. Generally, only the debts that accumulated during a relationship <span class="noglossary">will</span> be shared between married spouses and unmarried spouses.


Married spouses also have to decide about whether they want to get divorced. Divorce is the legal termination of a marriage, and only a judge can make you divorced. Most married spouses whose relationship has ended want to get divorced, but it's usually a low priority. Couples who aren't married, including unmarried spouses, never need to get divorced.
Married spouses also have to decide about whether they want to get divorced. Divorce is the legal ending of a marriage, and only a judge can make you divorced. Most married spouses whose relationship has ended want to get divorced, but it's usually a low priority. Couples who aren't married, including unmarried spouses, never need to get divorced.


All of these family law problems <span class="noglossary">will</span> be discussed in more detail later on.
All of these family law problems <span class="noglossary">will</span> be discussed in more detail later on.
Line 66: Line 67:
As you can see, the sorts of family law problems a couple can have sometimes depends on what their relationship was like. In family law, there are four main types of relationship:
As you can see, the sorts of family law problems a couple can have sometimes depends on what their relationship was like. In family law, there are four main types of relationship:


#'''Unmarried couples.''' An unmarried couple probably think of themselves as boyfriend and girlfriend. They may have lived together, but not for too long. Sometimes an unmarried couple involved in a family law problem <span class="noglossary">will</span> have been together only for a very short while ― perhaps just long enough to make a baby.
#'''Unmarried adults.''' Unmarried adults probably think of themselves as boyfriends and girlfriends. They may have lived together, but not for too long. Sometimes unmarried adults involved in a family law problem <span class="noglossary">will</span> have been together only for a very short while ― perhaps just long enough to make a baby.
#'''Unmarried spouses.''' Unmarried spouses are not legally married. Unmarried spouses have lived together in a loving relationship, and, for most purposes of the ''[[Family Law Act]]'', must have lived together for at least two years or for less than two years if the couple have had a child together.
#'''Unmarried spouses.''' Unmarried spouses are not legally married. Unmarried spouses have lived together in a loving relationship, and, for most purposes of the ''[[Family Law Act]]'', must have lived together for at least two years or for less than two years if they have had a child together.
#'''Married spouses.''' Married spouses have been legally married, by a marriage commissioner or a religious official licensed to perform marriages, and their marriage has been registered with the government where they were married.
#'''Married spouses.''' Married spouses have been legally married, by a marriage commissioner or a religious official licensed to perform marriages, and their marriage has been registered with the government where they were married.
#'''Parents.''' Parents are people who have had a baby together, sometimes including people who helped as the donor of sperm, the donor of eggs or a surrogate mother. Parents may be an unmarried couple, unmarried spouses, married spouses or complete strangers. What matters is that they have a child.   
#'''Parents.''' Parents are people who have had a baby together, sometimes including people who helped as the donor of sperm, the donor of eggs or a surrogate mother. Parents may be unmarried adults, unmarried spouses, married spouses or complete strangers. What matters is that they have a child.   


'''Further reading:'''
'''Further reading:'''
Line 81: Line 82:
==Resolving family law problems==
==Resolving family law problems==


If you have a family problem now, or might have one in the future, you have two ways to resolve that problem: you can talk to the other person and try make a decision about the problem together; or, you can ask someone else to make the decision for you. Really, there's also a third option. You could also walk away refuse to deal with the problem, and wait to see what happens. This is a terrible way of dealing with family law problems.
If you have a family problem now, or might have one in the future, you have two ways to resolve that problem: you can talk to the other person and try make a decision about the problem together; or, you can ask someone else to make the decision for you. Really, there's also a third option. You could also walk away refuse to deal with the problem, and wait to see what happens. This is usually a terrible way of dealing with family law problems.


If you want to try to make a decision about the problem together, you and the other adults involved in the problem will need to agree on a resolution and your decision will usually be written down in a formal agreement. Reaching an agreement usually requires negotiation. You can negotiate face to face, or do it through lawyers. ''Mediation'' is a kind of negotiation that uses a specially-trained mediator to help people talk to each other and find a resolution. ''Collaborative settlement processes'' are a kind of negotiation that uses specially-trained lawyers, and sometimes people who are experts about money or experts about children, who work together to help people talk to each other.  
If you want to try to make a decision about the problem together, you and the other adults involved in the problem will need to agree on a resolution and your decision will usually be written down in a formal way. Reaching an agreement usually requires negotiation. You can negotiate face to face, or do it through lawyers. ''Mediation'' is a kind of negotiation that uses a specially-trained person, a ''mediator'', to help people talk to each other and find a resolution. ''Collaborative negotiation'' is a kind of negotiation that uses specially-trained lawyers, and sometimes also people who are experts about money or experts about children, who work together to help people talk to each other.  


If you want to ask someone to make a decision about the problem, you can go to court or you can go to an arbitrator. If you ''litigate'', you will start a public court proceeding governed by the formal rules of court that will conclude months or years later with a trial before a judge, if your family problem isn't resolved before then. If you ''arbitrate'', you will start a private proceeding governed by rules you can help design that will conclude months later with a hearing before an arbitrator.  
If you want to ask someone to make a decision about the problem, you can go to court or you can go to an arbitrator. If you ''litigate'', you will start a public court proceeding managed by the rules of court that will conclude a few years later with a trial before a judge, if your family problem isn't resolved by an agreement before then. If you ''arbitrate'', you will start a private process governed by rules you can help design that will conclude a few months later with a hearing before an arbitrator.  


Court proceedings usually end with the judge's ''order''. Arbitration proceedings end with the arbitrator's ''award''. Negotiation usually ends with a settlement that is written down as an ''agreement'', but if you can negotiate a deal in the middle of a court proceeding, the settlement might be written down as a ''consent order''. If you negotiate a deal in the middle of an arbitration proceeding, the settlement might be written as a ''consent award''. Orders, awards and agreements are for family law problems that you have now. Agreements are also used for family law problems that you might have in the future.  
Court proceedings usually end with the judge's ''order''. Arbitration proceedings end with the arbitrator's ''award''. Negotiation usually ends with a settlement that is written down as a legal ''agreement'', but if you can reach a deal in the middle of a court proceeding, the settlement might be written down as a ''consent order''. If you negotiate a deal in the middle of an arbitration proceeding, the settlement might be written as a ''consent award''. Orders, awards and agreements are for family law problems that you have now. Agreements are also used to address family law problems that you might have in the future.  


'''Further reading:'''
'''Further reading:'''
Line 97: Line 98:
===Family law agreements===
===Family law agreements===


A family law agreement is a contract, like the contract you might have with your landlord or your employer, or the contract you might sign if you lease a car. Family law agreements are used to record a couple's agreement on legal issues that they're dealing with when they make the agreement, or may have to deal with at some point in the future.  
A family law agreement is a legal contract, like the contract you might have with your landlord or your employer, or the contract you might sign if you lease a car. Family law agreements are used to record people's settlement of the legal issues that they're dealing with when they make the agreement. They may also deal issues that might come up in the future.  


There are three kinds of agreement a couple can make about family law issues:
There are three kinds of agreement people can make about family law issues:


#living-togther or cohabitation agreements, agreements that a couple may make when they are living together or plan to live together,
#''living-togther'' or ''cohabitation'' agreements, agreements that people may make when they are living together or plan to live together,
#marriage agreements, which a couple may want if they are going to be getting married, and
#''marriage agreements'', which a couple may want if they are going to be getting married, and
#separation agreements, which a married or unmarried couple may make after their relationship ends.
#''separation agreements'', which a married spouses or unmarried adults may make after their relationship ends.


''Cohabitation agreement''s and ''marriage agreements'' are for couples who are just starting a relationship. These sorts of agreements can talk about how the relationship <span class="noglossary">will</span> be managed (who <span class="noglossary">will</span> pay the bills, <span class="noglossary">will</span> there be a joint bank <span class="noglossary">account</span> or a joint credit card, or who <span class="noglossary">will</span> do what parts of the housework), but most often talk about what <span class="noglossary">will</span> happen if the relationship ends. These agreements are usually meant to stop a couple from fighting after a relationship ends by setting out who <span class="noglossary">will</span> get what right from the start.
Cohabitation agreements and marriage agreements are for people who are just starting a relationship. These sorts of agreements can talk about how the relationship <span class="noglossary">will</span> be managed (who <span class="noglossary">will</span> pay the bills, <span class="noglossary">will</span> there be a joint bank <span class="noglossary">account</span> or a joint credit card, or who <span class="noglossary">will</span> do what parts of the housework), but most often talk about what <span class="noglossary">will</span> happen if the relationship ends. These agreements are usually meant to stop people from fighting after a relationship ends by setting out who <span class="noglossary">will</span> get what right from the start.


''The law does not require that a couple make a cohabitation agreement or a marriage agreement when they start to live together or marry. You don't have to sign an agreement like this if you don't want to.''
''The law does not require that people make a cohabitation agreement or a marriage agreement when they start to live together or marry. You don't have to sign an agreement like this if you don't want to.''


Cohabitation agreements and marriage agreements aren't for everyone. People who are bringing a lot of property, money, or children into a relationship may want a cohabitation agreement or a marriage agreement. People who don't have property or children, are young, and expect to have a long-term relationship may not need an agreement.
Cohabitation agreements and marriage agreements aren't for everyone. People who are bringing a lot of property, money, or children into a relationship may want a cohabitation agreement or a marriage agreement. People who don't have property or children, are young, and expect to have a long-term relationship may not need an agreement at all.


''Separation agreements'' are made after a relationship has ended. They talk about how a couple has agreed to deal with things like the care of children, child support and spousal support, and how the family assets <span class="noglossary">will</span> be shared. Separation agreements don't have to cover all the family law problems a couple have. They can deal with just some of those problems and leave the rest for the court to decide.
''Separation agreements'' are made after a relationship has ended. They talk about how a couple has agreed to deal with things like the care of children, child support and spousal support, and how the family assets <span class="noglossary">will</span> be shared. Separation agreements don't have to cover all the family law problems people have. They can deal with just some of those problems and leave the rest for the court or an arbitrator to decide.


Normally a couple who are thinking about a separation agreement talk about the issues and try to negotiate a resolution that they are both happy with. It is unusual for just one person to write a separation agreement without talking to the other person. ''You do not have to sign a separation agreement if you don't want to.''
Normally people who are thinking about a separation agreement talk about the issues and try to negotiate a resolution that they are both happy with. It is unusual for just one person to write a separation agreement without talking to the other person. ''You do not have to sign a separation agreement if you don't want to.''


No matter what kind of family law agreement you have signed, you both expect that each of you <span class="noglossary">will</span> follow the agreement, and that the court <span class="noglossary">will</span> enforce the agreement if you don't follow it. The court <span class="noglossary">will</span> generally respect an agreement that a couple willingly signed, as long as the agreement was fair and neither person misled the other person about something important, like money or property.
No matter what kind of family law agreement you have signed, each of the people involved in the agreement expect that the other <span class="noglossary">will</span> follow the agreement, and that the court <span class="noglossary">will</span> enforce the agreement if someone doesn't follow it. The court <span class="noglossary">will</span> generally respect an agreement that people signed willingly, as long as the agreement was fair and no one misled anyone else about something important, like money or property.


'''Further reading:'''
'''Further reading:'''
Line 123: Line 124:
===The courts of British Columbia===
===The courts of British Columbia===


There are three levels of court in British Columbia: the Provincial Court, the Supreme Court, and the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal is the highest court in the province and the Provincial Court is the lowest. The Provincial Court and the Supreme Court are ''trial courts'', which means that if litigants can't solve a legal problem for themselves, the court can make decisions resolving those problems after hearing from witnesses and considering the other evidence presented at a formal trial. The Court of Appeal is an ''appeal court'', meaning that it doesn't hold trials, it just hears arguments about whether the decision of a trial court was correct or incorrect. Most family law litigation happens in the Provincial Court and the Supreme Court.  
There are three levels of court in British Columbia: the Provincial Court, the Supreme Court, and the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal is the highest court in the province and the Provincial Court is the lowest. The Provincial Court and the Supreme Court are ''trial courts'', which means that if the people involved in a court case (the ''parties'' or the ''litigants'') can't solve a legal problem for themselves, the court can make decisions resolving those problems for them, after hearing from witnesses and considering the other evidence presented at a formal trial. The Court of Appeal is an ''appeal court'', meaning that it doesn't hold trials, it just hears arguments about whether the decision of a trial court was correct or incorrect. Most family law litigation happens in the Provincial Court and the Supreme Court.  


The branch of the Provincial Court that deals with family law is called the Provincial (Family) Court. Other branches of the Provincial Court include the Provincial (Youth) Court and the Provincial (Small Claims) Court. (When this resource talks about the Provincial (Family) Court, it will just say the Provincial Court.) The Provincial Court can deal with:
The branch of the Provincial Court that deals with family law is called the Provincial (Family) Court. Other branches of the Provincial Court include the Provincial (Youth) Court and the Provincial (Small Claims) Court. (When this resource talks about the Provincial (Family) Court, it will just say the Provincial Court.) The Provincial Court can deal with: