Difference between revisions of "Child Support Guidelines"

Jump to navigation Jump to search
m
no edit summary
m
Line 6: Line 6:
}}
}}


Often simply referred to as the Guidelines, the [http://canlii.ca/t/80mh Child Support Guidelines]', SOR/97-175, is a federal regulation, adopted by all of the provinces except Quebec, that describes the rules that the courts must apply when making an order for child support. The most important feature of the Guidelines is the child support tables which fix the amount of support payments according to the annual income of the person paying support and the number of support is to be paid for. The Guidelines cover every aspect of child support, including the calculation of income, how children's special expenses are paid for, the amount of support payable when the parents have the children for an almost equal amount of time and the amount payable when one or more of the children live full-time with each parent.
Often simply referred to as the Guidelines, the [http://canlii.ca/t/80mh Child Support Guidelines]', SOR/97-175, is a federal regulation, adopted by all of the provinces except Quebec, that describes the rules that the courts must apply when making an order for child support. The most important feature of the Guidelines is the child support tables that fix the amount of support payments according to the annual income of the person paying support and the number of support is to be paid for. The Guidelines cover every aspect of child support, including the calculation of income, how children's special expenses are paid for, the amount of support payable when the parents have the children for an almost equal amount of time, and the amount payable when one or more of the children live full-time with each parent.


This page talks about the basic principles of the Guidelines, the sharing of special and extraordinary expenses, the calculation of income, imputing income, and the circumstances in which the income of a parent's or guardian's new partner may be taken into account. It also provides an example of the contents of a typical child support order.
This section talks about the basic principles of the Guidelines, the sharing of special and extraordinary expenses, the calculation of income, imputing income, and the circumstances in which the income of a parent's or guardian's new partner may be taken into account. It also provides an example of the contents of a typical child support order.


==Basic principles==
==Basic principles==


It used to be the case that the party claiming support, the ''recipient'', had to jump through all sorts of hoops to show the amount of support the child needed and prove that the person being asked to pay support, the ''payor'', had the means to pay that amount. These days, the amount of a child support order or an agreement for child support is based on the amounts set out in the tables attached to the Child Support Guidelines. The Guidelines has generally reduced the amount of time and money that parents spend fighting about child support, whether they're in court arguing about an order or are negotiating the amount of support for a separation agreement.
It used to be the case that the party claiming support, the ''recipient'', had to jump through all sorts of hoops to show the amount of support the child needed and prove that the person being asked to pay support, the ''payor'', had the means to pay that amount. These days, the amount of a child support order or an agreement for child support is based on the amounts set out in the tables attached to the Child Support Guidelines. The Guidelines have generally reduced the amount of time and money that parents spend fighting about child support, whether they're in court arguing about an order, or are negotiating the amount of support for a separation agreement.


The Guidelines tables were most recently adjusted on 31 December 2011. The amount of child support required of lower earning parents was reduced and the amount of support for higher earning parents was increased, although none of the changes were particularly dramatic. If you are relying on a printed version of the child support tables to figure out how much child support should be paid, make sure that your materials reflect the new table amounts.
The Guidelines tables were most recently adjusted on 31 December 2011. The amount of child support required of lower earning parents was reduced and the amount of support for higher earning parents was increased, although none of the changes were particularly dramatic. If you are relying on a printed version of the child support tables to figure out how much child support should be paid, make sure that your materials reflect the new table amounts.
Line 22: Line 22:
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(b) the amount, if any, determined under s. 7.</tt></blockquote></blockquote>
<blockquote><blockquote><tt>(b) the amount, if any, determined under s. 7.</tt></blockquote></blockquote>


This is, however, only a presumption, and can be challenged or ''rebutted'', as is discussed in the page on [[Exceptions to the Child Support Guidelines]] within this chapter.  In the vast majority of cases, however, the amount of child support payable is calculated using the payor's gross annual income at the time the order is made.
This is, however, only a presumption, and can be challenged or ''rebutted'', as is discussed in the section[[Exceptions to the Child Support Guidelines]] within this chapter.  In the vast majority of cases, however, the amount of child support payable is calculated using the payor's gross annual income at the time the order is made.


Over time, of course, the payor's income may go up or down. Both the payor and the recipient can make an application to change the original order so that the amount of child support reflects the payor's current income. The payor would typically make the application if his or her income has fallen, while the recipient would make the application when the payor's income has increased. To avoid a situation where parents are continually making trips back to court to seek an adjustment of child support, it's a good idea to include a term that requires both parties to regularly exchange income information in an agreement or order for child support, so that child support support can be adjusted from time to time without having to go to court.
Over time, of course, the payor's income may go up or down. Both the payor and the recipient can make an application to change the original order so that the amount of child support reflects the payor's current income. The payor would typically make the application if his or her income has fallen, while the recipient would make the application when the payor's income has increased. To avoid a situation where parents are continually making trips back to court to seek an adjustment of child support, it's a good idea to include a term that requires both parties to regularly exchange income information in an agreement or order for child support, so that child support support can be adjusted from time to time without having to go to court.
Line 61: Line 61:
Just because an expense appears to fall into one of the categories listed in s. 7 of the Guidelines doesn't necessarily make it a shareable special and/or extraordinary expense. As well, just because an expense has been incurred doesn't mean it will automatically be shared; if you're not sure whether a planned expense will qualify as a shareable special expense, get some legal advice or talk to the other parent first.
Just because an expense appears to fall into one of the categories listed in s. 7 of the Guidelines doesn't necessarily make it a shareable special and/or extraordinary expense. As well, just because an expense has been incurred doesn't mean it will automatically be shared; if you're not sure whether a planned expense will qualify as a shareable special expense, get some legal advice or talk to the other parent first.


According to s. 7(1) of the Guidelines, the court must not only find that an expense fits into one of the categories listed above, but also consider
According to s. 7(1) of the Guidelines, the court must not only find that an expense fits into one of the categories listed above, but also consider:


#the "reasonableness of the expense in relation to the means of the spouses and those of the child and to the family's spending pattern prior to the separation," and
#the "reasonableness of the expense in relation to the means of the spouses and those of the child and to the family's spending pattern prior to the separation," and
#the necessity of the expense in relation to the child's best interests,
#the necessity of the expense in relation to the child's best interests,


bearing in mind the special test for primary- and secondary-school education and extracurricular activities required by s. 7(1.1). Here's a helpful summary from a 2010 case from our Supreme Court, ''[http://canlii.ca/t/2dpzr Piper v. Piper]'', 2010 BCSC 1718:
The court must bear in mind the special test for primary- and secondary-school education and extracurricular activities required by s. 7(1.1). Here's a helpful summary from a 2010 case from our Supreme Court, ''[http://canlii.ca/t/2dpzr Piper v. Piper]'', 2010 BCSC 1718:


<blockquote>"Under s. 7(1.1)(a) the court is first required to consider whether the income of the requesting spouse, including any child support received, can reasonably cover the expense claimed or whether the expense exceeds her ability to pay without any consideration of the factors enumerated in s. 7(1.1)(b). If the income cannot cover the expense, the expense is deemed to be extraordinary and the court's next analysis turns to consideration of the factors enumerated in s. 7(1) which, of course, brings into consideration the parties' means and pre-separation spending pattern."</blockquote>
<blockquote>"Under s. 7(1.1)(a) the court is first required to consider whether the income of the requesting spouse, including any child support received, can reasonably cover the expense claimed or whether the expense exceeds her ability to pay without any consideration of the factors enumerated in s. 7(1.1)(b). If the income cannot cover the expense, the expense is deemed to be extraordinary and the court's next analysis turns to consideration of the factors enumerated in s. 7(1) which, of course, brings into consideration the parties' means and pre-separation spending pattern."</blockquote>
Line 104: Line 104:
===Sharing qualifying expenses===
===Sharing qualifying expenses===


Under s. 7(2) of the Guidelines, expenses which qualify as special and/or extraordinary expenses are shared by the parties in proportion to their incomes, after deducting any contribution to those costs made by the child or the government, through things like grants or tax deductions. The idea here is to look at the total pot of money available to the child — the income of the payor plus the income of the recipient — and to figure how much each party's share of that pot is, and then pay the child's special expenses according to each parent's share.
Under s. 7(2) of the Guidelines, expenses that qualify as special and/or extraordinary expenses are shared by the parties in proportion to their incomes, after deducting any contribution to those costs made by the child or the government, through things like grants or tax deductions. The idea here is to look at the total pot of money available to the child — the income of the payor plus the income of the recipient — and to figure how much each party's share of that pot is, and then pay the child's special expenses according to each parent's share.


The easiest way to calculate a parent's ''proportionate share'' is to add the incomes of both parents together and then figure out what percentage each income is of the total. Here are two examples.
The easiest way to calculate a parent's ''proportionate share'' is to add the incomes of both parents together and then figure out what percentage each income is of the total. Here are two examples.
Line 117: Line 117:
<blockquote>If one parent earns $48,000 per year and the other $62,000, the total of their incomes is $110,000. The first parent's income is 43.6% of the total, and the other parent's income is 56.4% of the total. The first parent would have to pay 43.6% of all qualifying special expenses, and the second would have to pay 54.6% of those expenses.</blockquote>
<blockquote>If one parent earns $48,000 per year and the other $62,000, the total of their incomes is $110,000. The first parent's income is 43.6% of the total, and the other parent's income is 56.4% of the total. The first parent would have to pay 43.6% of all qualifying special expenses, and the second would have to pay 54.6% of those expenses.</blockquote>


The cost that is being shared is the ''net cost'' of an expense, in other words, the amount that is actually being paid after any third party contributions have been applied to reduce the expense. Daycare costs, for example, are usually partly subsidized by the government with certain tax deductions. If $1,000 is spent on daycare, but the government chips in a $200 tax benefit, the amount of the expense shared between the parents would be $800, not the full $1,000.
The cost that is being shared is the ''net cost'' of an expense, in other words, the amount that is actually being paid after any third-party contributions have been applied to reduce the expense. Daycare costs, for example, are usually partly subsidized by the government with certain tax deductions. If $1,000 is spent on daycare, but the government chips in a $200 tax benefit, the amount of the expense shared between the parents would be $800, not the full $1,000.


Note that the income of a parent's new spouse or partner can be taken into consideration in determining a parent's "means" in sharing a special expense. In the 2000 Supreme Court case of ''[http://canlii.ca/t/1fm6b Baum v. Baum]'', 2000 BCSC 1835 the court held that the s. 7(1) consideration of the "means of the spouses" should be interpreted broadly as including all sources of income available to the paying parent, including the income of a parent's new partner.
Note that the income of a parent's new spouse or partner can be taken into consideration in determining a parent's "means" in sharing a special expense. In the 2000 Supreme Court case of ''[http://canlii.ca/t/1fm6b Baum v. Baum]'', 2000 BCSC 1835 the court held that the s. 7(1) consideration of the "means of the spouses" should be interpreted broadly as including all sources of income available to the paying parent, including the income of a parent's new partner.
Line 125: Line 125:
Before the court even looks at the Child Support Guidelines tables it has to decide what the payor's income is. The tables set out the amount of child support payable according to the payor's income. The Guidelines require that the court use the most up-to-date information available. Sections 15 to 20 of the Guidelines set out the rules the court must apply in determing income.
Before the court even looks at the Child Support Guidelines tables it has to decide what the payor's income is. The tables set out the amount of child support payable according to the payor's income. The Guidelines require that the court use the most up-to-date information available. Sections 15 to 20 of the Guidelines set out the rules the court must apply in determing income.


According to Rule 5-1 of the [http://canlii.ca/t/8mcr Supreme Court Family Rules] and Rule 4 of the [http://canlii.ca/t/85pb Provincial Court (Family) Rules], when someone makes an application for child support, the payor or both the payor and recipient are required to disclosure their financial circumstances using court form called a Financial Statement. Financial Statements require each party to set out their income and expenses, and assets and liabilities. Certain income documents must be attached to a Financial Statement, typically:
According to Rule 5-1 of the [http://canlii.ca/t/8mcr Supreme Court Family Rules] and Rule 4 of the [http://canlii.ca/t/85pb Provincial Court (Family) Rules], when someone makes an application for child support, the payor or both the payor and recipient are required to disclosure their financial circumstances using court form called a Financial Statement. Financial statements require each party to set out their income and expenses, and assets and liabilities. Certain income documents must be attached to a financial statement, typically:


#the last three years' worth of tax returns (what's required is the complete income tax and benefit return, not tax return "summaries" or "informations"),
#the last three years' worth of tax returns (what's required is the complete income tax and benefit return, not tax return "summaries" or "informations"),
#all Notices of Assessment and Reassessment received for the last three tax years,
#all notices of assessment and reassessment received for the last three tax years,
#the party's most recent paystub, showing his or her earnings to date, or if the party isn't working, then his or her most recent WCB statement, social assistance statement or EI statement, and
#the party's most recent paystub, showing his or her earnings to date, or if the party isn't working, then his or her most recent WCB statement, social assistance statement, or EI statement, and
#business records like financial statements and corporate income tax returns, if the party has a company.
#business records like financial statements and corporate income tax returns, if the party has a company.


Line 138: Line 138:
===Government benefits===
===Government benefits===


Payments from WCB, Employment Insurance, CPP, Old Age Security and welfare all count as income under the Guidelines. If a party is receiving these payments as a temporary subsitute for employment income, the party's income may be assessed at his or her usual income. A temporary period on welfare, for example, won't entitle a payor to have his or her income assessed at that unusually low level.
Payments from WCB, Employment Insurance, CPP, Old Age Security, and welfare all count as income under the Guidelines. If a party is receiving these payments as a temporary subsitute for employment income, the party's income may be assessed at his or her usual income. A temporary period on welfare, for example, won't entitle a payor to have his or her income assessed at that unusually low level.


===Fluctuating income===
===Fluctuating income===
Line 146: Line 146:
===Unexpected losses and gains===
===Unexpected losses and gains===


Where a payor has suffered an unexpected loss, such as a corporate loss or an investment loss, or enjoyed an unexpected gain, such as from cashing in RRSPs or selling stock, the court has the discretion to decide to take this into consideration in setting the payor's income, and potentially not consider the loos or gain.
Where a payor has suffered an unexpected loss, such as a corporate loss or an investment loss, or enjoyed an unexpected gain, such as from cashing in RRSPs or selling stock, the court has the discretion to decide to take this into consideration in setting the payor's income, and potentially not consider the loss or gain.


===Court awards===
===Court awards===
Line 236: Line 236:
==Child support and parents' new partners==
==Child support and parents' new partners==


Parents and guardians usually move on with their lives after the relationship which produced their children has ended, meet new people and enter into new romantic relationships. Parents and their new partners are often concerned about how their relationship will impact on the parent's obligation to pay child support. The parent might be concerned to know whether the new partner's income will be added to his or her income in calculating child support. The new partner will want to know whether he or she is now on the hook for support and must contribute to the parent's payments or towards the parent's children.
Parents and guardians usually move on with their lives after the relationship that produced their children has ended. They will meet new people and enter into new romantic relationships. Parents and their new partners are often concerned about how their relationship will impact on the parent's obligation to pay child support. The parent might be concerned to know whether the new partner's income will be added to his or her income in calculating child support. The new partner will want to know whether he or she is now on the hook for support and must contribute to the parent's payments or towards the parent's children.


===Basic child support payments===
===Basic child support payments===
Line 246: Line 246:
===Undue hardship claims===
===Undue hardship claims===


Section 10 of the Child Support Guidelines allows parties to argue that the base amount of support set out in the Guidelines tables is too low or too high and would cause ''undue hardship'' if the table amount was paid. Payors will claim that the base amount is too high, while recipients will argue that it is too low. This exception to the Guidelines is discussed more thoroughly in page on [[Exceptions to the Child Support Guidelines]] in this chapter.
Section 10 of the Child Support Guidelines allows parties to argue that the base amount of support set out in the Guidelines tables is too low or too high and would cause ''undue hardship'' if the table amount was paid. Payors will claim that the base amount is too high, while recipients will argue that it is too low. This exception to the Guidelines is discussed more thoroughly in the section [[Exceptions to the Child Support Guidelines]].


If undue hardship is claimed, the court will look at the standard of living of each parent's ''household'', rather than the standard of living of each parent alone. This means that the court, in deciding whether there is undue hardship, will look at the total expenses and total income of each parent's household, including the income of each parent's new partner. This will not cause the new partner to be liable to pay support, it just means that his or her income will be added to the parent's income to see whether the usual table amount of support payable is unduly high or low.
If undue hardship is claimed, the court will look at the standard of living of each parent's ''household'', rather than the standard of living of each parent alone. This means that the court, in deciding whether there is undue hardship, will look at the total expenses and total income of each parent's household, including the income of each parent's new partner. This will not cause the new partner to be liable to pay support, it just means that his or her income will be added to the parent's income to see whether the usual table amount of support payable is unduly high or low.
Line 254: Line 254:
The tables provided in the Child Support Guidelines set out the amount of support owing by payors who earn up to $150,000 per year. The Guidelines provide a mathematical formula for figuring out what parents earning more than $150,000 must pay, while payors earning less than $10,800 pay nothing.
The tables provided in the Child Support Guidelines set out the amount of support owing by payors who earn up to $150,000 per year. The Guidelines provide a mathematical formula for figuring out what parents earning more than $150,000 must pay, while payors earning less than $10,800 pay nothing.


Section 4 of the Guidelines deals with parents who earn more than $150,000 each year. Under this section, the income (or lack of income) of a parent's new partner may be taken into account in deciding whether the formula gives a fair result. The calculation of support owing by parents with incomes in excess of $150,000 is discussed in more detail in the page [[Exceptions to Child Support Guidelines]].
Section 4 of the Guidelines deals with parents who earn more than $150,000 each year. Under this section, the income (or lack of income) of a parent's new partner may be taken into account in deciding whether the formula gives a fair result. The calculation of support owing by parents with incomes in excess of $150,000 is discussed in more detail in [[Exceptions to Child Support Guidelines]].


Section 4(b)(ii) of the Guidelines says that when considering the amount payable above the basic amount for a payor whose annual income is $150,000, the court should apply the formula but take into account:
Section 4(b)(ii) of the Guidelines says that when considering the amount payable above the basic amount for a payor whose annual income is $150,000, the court should apply the formula but take into account:
Line 264: Line 264:
===Special expenses===
===Special expenses===


Section 7 of the Guidelines allows for sharing of the children's special and/or extraordinary expenses between the parents, as discussed above. In figuring out how much a parent should have to contribute to these expenses, the court is required to take into account, among other things "the reasonableness of the expense in relation to the means of the spouses and those of the child".
Section 7 of the Guidelines allows for sharing of the children's special and/or extraordinary expenses between the parents, as discussed above. In figuring out how much a parent should have to contribute to these expenses, the court is required to take into account, among other things "the reasonableness of the expense in relation to the means of the spouses and those of the child."


A parent's new partner's income can be taken into consideration in assessing the "means of the spouses," which is exactly what the court did in the 2000 Supreme Court case of ''[http://canlii.ca/t/1fm6b Baum v. Baum]'', 2000 BCSC 1835. In that decision, the court held that ''means of the spouses'' should be interpreted broadly as including all of the means available to the paying parent, including the income of his or her new partner.
A parent's new partner's income can be taken into consideration in assessing the "means of the spouses," which is exactly what the court did in the 2000 Supreme Court case of ''[http://canlii.ca/t/1fm6b Baum v. Baum]'', 2000 BCSC 1835. In that decision, the court held that ''means of the spouses'' should be interpreted broadly as including all of the means available to the paying parent, including the income of his or her new partner.
Line 274: Line 274:
A number of readers have asked whether they will have any responsibility to make child support payments if their partner, a parent or guardian under an obligation to pay child support, dies. The simple answer to that question is no, they will have no responsibility. The fact that they are in a relationship with a paying parent doesn't necessarily mean that they will have a duty to keep paying support if that parent dies.
A number of readers have asked whether they will have any responsibility to make child support payments if their partner, a parent or guardian under an obligation to pay child support, dies. The simple answer to that question is no, they will have no responsibility. The fact that they are in a relationship with a paying parent doesn't necessarily mean that they will have a duty to keep paying support if that parent dies.


While that is a good general rule, and one you can probably rely on, it is possible that a claim could be made against the new partner as a ''stepparent'' of the child under the ''[[Family Law Act]]''. The act says that all parents, guardians and stepparents are required to support their children, but s. 147 says that stepparents who are obliged to pay child support must have contributed to the support of the child for at least of one year. In other words, a new partner who marries a paying parent may have an obligation if he or she has contributed to the support of the child. Again, while this is technically possible, orders against new partners following the death of the paying parent are extremely rare.
While that is a good general rule, and one you can probably rely on, it is possible that a claim could be made against the new partner as a ''stepparent'' of the child under the ''[[Family Law Act]]''. The act says that all parents, guardians, and stepparents are required to support their children, but s. 147 says that stepparents who are obliged to pay child support must have contributed to the support of the child for at least of one year. In other words, a new partner who marries a paying parent may have an obligation if he or she has contributed to the support of the child. Again, while this is technically possible, orders against new partners following the death of the paying parent are extremely rare.


==Agreemements and orders for child support==
==Agreemements and orders for child support==
Line 285: Line 285:
#a declaration of the payor's income,
#a declaration of the payor's income,
#an order as to the Guidelines amount payable,
#an order as to the Guidelines amount payable,
#an order with respect to the exchange of income information, and
#an order about the exchange of income information, and
#a statement of the date on which child support will no longer be payable.
#a statement of the date on which child support will no longer be payable.


Line 314: Line 314:
===Agreements for child support===
===Agreements for child support===


Separation agreements, like all family law agreements, have two types of statements. The ''recitals'' are statements that talk about the parties and their relationship that explain their background and why they signed their agreement. The ''operative clauses'' of an agreement are statements that say what each party has promised to do. The recitals to a separation agreement about child support would include statements like these:
Separation agreements, like all family law agreements, have two types of statements. The ''recitals'' are statements that talk about the parties and their relationship. They explain the parties' background and why they signed their agreement. The ''operative clauses'' of an agreement are statements that say what each party has promised to do.  
 
The recitals to a separation agreement about child support would include statements like these:


<blockquote><tt>D. Jane Doe is a plumber working for ABC Plumbing, eaning about $72,000 per year.</tt></blockquote>
<blockquote><tt>D. Jane Doe is a plumber working for ABC Plumbing, eaning about $72,000 per year.</tt></blockquote>
Line 344: Line 346:
* <span style="color: red;">bulleted list of other pages in this chapter, linked</span>
* <span style="color: red;">bulleted list of other pages in this chapter, linked</span>
END HIDDEN--->
END HIDDEN--->
==Page resources and links==
==Resources and links==


===Legislation===
===Legislation===
Line 361: Line 363:
* [http://www.clicklaw.bc.ca/resource/1618 Legal Services Society Family Law Website: Child support]
* [http://www.clicklaw.bc.ca/resource/1618 Legal Services Society Family Law Website: Child support]


{{REVIEWED | reviewer = [[JP Boyd]], March 24, 2013}}
{{JP Boyd on Family Law Navbox|type=chapters}}
{{JP Boyd on Family Law Navbox|type=chapters}}
2,443

edits

Navigation menu