Difference between revisions of "Creditors' Remedies against Debtors (10:III)"

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
Line 324: Line 324:
*d) the address of the garnishee’s residence in the jurisdiction (s 3(2)).  
*d) the address of the garnishee’s residence in the jurisdiction (s 3(2)).  


The affidavit is filed in the court registry along with the form of order requested.    The garnishee is then to be served with a copy of the order, which commands them to pay the money into court.  A copy of the order must be served on the debtor at once, or within a time allowed by the judge or registrar by memorandum endorsed on the order . Failure to serve a garnishing order on a debtor “at once” may result in the garnishing order being set aside. Whether delayed service is fatal to a garnishing order depends on the circumstances of each case. See ''Skybound Developments Ltd. v. Hughes Properties Ltd.'' (1985), 1985 CarswellBC 219, 65 BCLR 79 (CA) for a discussion on this topic. The garnishee may dispute indebtedness to the judgment debtor (see '''Section II.B: Legal Advice for Debtors Who are Garnished''', below).  Where the garnishee pays money, the court keeps the money until it is paid out to the judgment creditor under ss 11, 12, and 13.
The affidavit is filed in the court registry along with the form of order requested.    The garnishee is then to be served with a copy of the order, which commands them to pay the money into court.  A copy of the order must be served on the debtor at once, or within a time allowed by the judge or registrar by memorandum endorsed on the order . Failure to serve a garnishing order on a debtor “at once” may result in the garnishing order being set aside. Whether delayed service is fatal to a garnishing order depends on the circumstances of each case. See ''[https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcca/doc/1985/1985canlii539/1985canlii539.html?autocompleteStr=Skybound%20&autocompletePos=2 Skybound Developments Ltd. v. Hughes Properties Ltd.'' (1985), 1985 CarswellBC 219, 65 BCLR 79 (CA)] for a discussion on this topic. The garnishee may dispute indebtedness to the judgment debtor (see '''Section II.B: Legal Advice for Debtors Who are Garnished''', below).  Where the garnishee pays money, the court keeps the money until it is paid out to the judgment creditor under ss 11, 12, and 13.


Funds held jointly to the credit of the defendant and another person, who is not a party to the action, cannot be garnished, except where a creditor bank exercises its right of offset: see ''238344 BC Ltd. v Patriquin et al'' (1984), 57 BCLR 224.  
Funds held jointly to the credit of the defendant and another person, who is not a party to the action, cannot be garnished, see ''[https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcca/doc/1984/1984canlii301/1984canlii301.html?autocompleteStr=238344%20BC%20Ltd%20v%20&autocompletePos=1 238344 BC Ltd v Patriquin et al'' (1984), 57 BCLR 224]. That case also cited cases of exceptions where a creditor bank exercised its right of offset, but ''238344 BC Ltd'' suggested these were wrongly decided.


==== e) Payment by Instalments ====
==== e) Payment by Instalments ====


A debtor against whom a garnishing order has been made may apply for a release of the garnishing order, and for an order for the payment of the debt by instalments on the basis of hardship (see ''Bank of Montreal v Monsell'' (1994), 58 BCLR 11 (SC)). This order, if granted (it is rare), will bind the debtor’s creditors, but will only continue for as long as the debtor is not in default on any payment for more than five days, and so long as no other garnishing order is issued against him or her for any other debt (s 5). The creditor may apply to have the order  varied if new evidence of the debtor’s finances comes to light.
A debtor against whom a garnishing order has been made may apply for a release of the garnishing order, and for an order for the payment of the debt by instalments on the basis of hardship. This order, if granted (it is rare), will bind the debtor’s creditors, but will only continue for as long as the debtor is not in default on any payment for more than five days, and so long as no other garnishing order is issued against them for any other debt (s 5). There is an exception where a creditor who elects to have a garnishing order changed to payment by instalments will be barred from seeking a garnishing order after the debtor defaults (see ''[https://www.canlii.org/en/bc/bcsc/doc/1984/1984canlii332/1984canlii332.html?autocompleteStr=Bank%20of%20Montreal%20v%20Monsell%20&autocompletePos=1 Bank of Montreal v Monsell'' (1994), 58 BCLR 11 (SC)]). The creditor may apply to have the order  varied if new evidence of the debtor’s finances comes to light.


=== 6. Garnishment of Wages ===
=== 6. Garnishment of Wages ===
5,109

edits

Navigation menu