Difference between revisions of "Creditors' Remedies against Debtors (10:III)"

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
Line 340: Line 340:
==== b) Deductions and Exempt Wages ====
==== b) Deductions and Exempt Wages ====


70 percent of any wages due by an employer to an employee is exempt from seizure or attachment under a garnishing order. Therefore, only 30 percent of wages after statutory deductions (i.e. Employment Insurance premiums, Canada Pension Plan, Income Tax, etc.) can be garnished (s 3(5)). However, a single person cannot be left with less than $100 per month (or calculated pro rata for a shorter period), and a person with dependents cannot be left with less than $200 per month (or calculated pro rata for a shorter period) (s 3(5)). However, where wages are garnished to pay maintenance or support for the debtor’s family, the exemptions allowed to that person are 50 percent of wages not exceeding $600 per month or 33 and 1/3 percent of wages exceeding $600 per month (''COEA'' s.3(7)). These exemptions must not be less than $100 per month (s 4(6)).  
70 percent of any wages due by an employer to an employee is exempt from seizure or attachment under a garnishing order. Therefore, only 30 percent of wages after statutory deductions (i.e. Employment Insurance premiums, Canada Pension Plan, Income Tax, etc.) can be garnished (s 3(5)). However, a single person cannot be left with less than $100 per month (or calculated pro rata for a shorter period), and a person with dependents cannot be left with less than $200 per month (or calculated pro rata for a shorter period) (s 3(5)). However, where wages are garnished to pay maintenance or support for the debtor’s family, the exemptions allowed to that person are 50 percent of wages not exceeding $600 per month or 33 and 1/3 percent of wages exceeding $600 per month (''COEA'' s.3(7)). These exemptions must not be less than $100 per month (s 3(7)).  


Garnishment by the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program is called a Notice of Attachment. The ''Family Maintenance Enforcement Act Regulation'',  BC Reg 346/88 contains rules about exemptions from attachment. These rules are different than those found in the ''COEA''.
Garnishment by the Family Maintenance Enforcement Program is called a Notice of Attachment. The ''Family Maintenance Enforcement Act Regulation'',  BC Reg 346/88 contains rules about exemptions from attachment. These rules are different than those found in the ''COEA''.
Line 346: Line 346:
==== c) Variation of Exemption ====
==== c) Variation of Exemption ====


A debtor whose wages are garnished may apply under s 4 to have the exemption varied. The registrar or judge shall, within three days after receiving the application, notify persons affected by it and a hearing will be held within seven days.  
A debtor whose wages are garnished may apply under s 4 of the COEA to have the exemption varied. The registrar or judge shall, within three days after receiving the application, notify persons affected by it and a hearing will be held within seven days.  


With respect to maintenance orders,  under s 18(2) of the ''Family Maintenance Enforcement Act'', upon application by a creditor, the court can issue a garnishing order against the debtor without giving notice.  
With respect to maintenance orders,  under s 18(2) of the ''Family Maintenance Enforcement Act'', upon application by a creditor, the court can issue a garnishing order against the debtor without giving notice.  
Line 354: Line 354:
==== d) Employer’s Liability for Firing Employee ====
==== d) Employer’s Liability for Firing Employee ====


No employer may fire or demote an employee because that employee has their wages garnished. An employer who does so is liable on summary conviction to a fine of up to $500 or up to three months in jail or both, and an employee can be reinstated with back pay if they are fired for garnishment of wages (s 27). One should consider the fact that the garnishment may have been the final reason among others for termination, and may be difficult to prove.
No employer may fire or demote an employee because that employee has their wages garnished. An employer who does so is liable on summary conviction to a fine of up to $500 or up to three months in jail or both, and an employee must be reinstated with back pay if they are fired for garnishment of wages (s 27). One should consider the fact that the garnishment may have been the final reason among others for termination, and may be difficult to prove.


=== 7. Garnishment of Statutory Benefits ===
=== 7. Garnishment of Statutory Benefits ===


'''Benefits including Employment Insurance, Canada Pension Plan, Old Age Security, workers compensation, social assistance and provincial disability benefits are usually exempt from garnishment, seizure or attachment.''' The exemptions are found in the statutes that govern these respective benefit programs.  
Benefits including Employment Insurance, Canada Pension Plan, Old Age Security, workers compensation, social assistance and provincial disability benefits are usually exempt from garnishment, seizure or attachment. The exemptions are found in the statutes that govern these respective benefit programs.


However, this exemption from garnishment does not apply to offsets or to debts to the government. For example debts to the federal crown may be collected from Canada Pension Plan benefits. Canada Revenue Agency is now routinely offsetting CPP and other benefits. Social assistance (welfare) is the only statutory benefit that is truly exempt from garnishment. '''The creditor or debtor should also be advised that this protection against garnishment may not extend to a bank account into which the exempt income is deposited if it is commingled with other funds.'''
However, this exemption from garnishment does not apply to offsets or to debts to the government. For example, debts to the federal crown may be collected from Canada Pension Plan benefits. Canada Revenue Agency is now routinely offsetting CPP and other benefits. Social assistance (welfare) is the only kind of statutory benefit that is truly exempt from garnishment. This also applies to Canadian Emergency Response Benefits and Canada Child Benefits received under the COVID-19 Emergency Response Act. '''The creditor or debtor should also be advised that this protection against garnishment may not extend to a bank account into which the exempt income is deposited if it is commingled with other funds.'''


=== 8. Enforcing a Judgment Outside of BC ===
=== 8. Enforcing a Judgment Outside of BC ===


It is possible to register a B.C. judgment in many foreign jurisdictions, including other Canadian provinces. The requirements for registration may differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, so the judgment creditor should consult with counsel in the destination jurisdiction to determine the specific requirements.  
It is possible to register a B.C. judgment in many foreign jurisdictions, including other Canadian provinces. The requirements for registration may differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, so the judgment creditor should consult with counsel in the destination jurisdiction to determine the specific requirements.


It is also possible, and sometimes more efficient, to sue on the judgment in the province or country where the judgment debtor’s assets are located. Normally the foreign court requires a certificate. To obtain a certificate in BC, creditors must file an application to the court that asks for a certificate to be issued (''COEA'' s 30).
It is also possible, and sometimes more efficient, to sue on the judgment in the province or country where the judgment debtor’s assets are located. Normally the foreign court requires a certificate. To obtain a certificate in BC, creditors must file an application to the court that asks for a certificate to be issued (''COEA'' s 30).


== C. Unsecured Creditors: Remedies and Options Before Judgment (Liens) ==
== C. Unsecured Creditors: Remedies and Options Before Judgment (Liens) ==
5,109

edits

Navigation menu