Difference between revisions of "I Was Harassed or Assaulted by the Police"

From Clicklaw Wikibooks
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(5 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
This section provides an overview of your legal options if you have been harassed or assaulted by the police, or if you are the victim of other types of improper police behaviour.  
This section provides an overview of your legal options if you have been harassed or assaulted by the police, or if you are the victim of other types of improper police behaviour.  


=1.0 What is improper police behaviour?=
=What is improper police behaviour?=
Examples of improper police behaviour include:
Examples of improper police behaviour include:
*using excessive force in the course of an arrest or investigation,
*using excessive force in the course of an arrest or investigation,
Line 11: Line 11:
*driving recklessly or dangerously.
*driving recklessly or dangerously.


=2.0 What are my options?=
=What are my options?=
You have at least three options. You could choose one or more of these:  
You have at least three options. You could choose one or more of these:  
*a police complaint,
*a police complaint,
Line 25: Line 25:
:A ''human rights complaint'' is filed with the BC or Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. These Tribunals are specialized to look into cases involving human rights abuses. A human rights complaint might lead to a settlement or judgment involving the payment of money.
:A ''human rights complaint'' is filed with the BC or Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. These Tribunals are specialized to look into cases involving human rights abuses. A human rights complaint might lead to a settlement or judgment involving the payment of money.


=3.0 When do I have to act?=
=When do I have to act?=


This depends on which option(s) you choose to pursue. For example:  
This depends on which option(s) you choose to pursue. For example:  
Line 66: Line 66:
:I write pursuant to s. 294(2) of the Vancouver Charter, SBC 1953, c 55, to put the City of Vancouver on notice that I will be commencing a civil claim for damages against the City of Vancouver and members of the Vancouver Police Department. I was injured by members of the VPD on [DATE] at or near [PLACE].
:I write pursuant to s. 294(2) of the Vancouver Charter, SBC 1953, c 55, to put the City of Vancouver on notice that I will be commencing a civil claim for damages against the City of Vancouver and members of the Vancouver Police Department. I was injured by members of the VPD on [DATE] at or near [PLACE].


=4.0 How should I prove my case?=  
=How should I prove my case?=  
==4.1 Write down what happened==
==Write down what happened==
Makes notes about the incident. These notes will help you recall details and may support your credibility down the road. You should include the following information:  
Makes notes about the incident. These notes will help you recall details and may support your credibility down the road. You should include the following information:  
*date and time of the incident,
*date and time of the incident,
Line 77: Line 77:
*what happened after the incident.
*what happened after the incident.


==4.2 Preserve the evidence==
==Preserve the evidence==
There might be evidence that could be used to prove what happened. It is important to keep it in a safe place. You may need it later to prove your version of events. Evidence might include:  
There might be evidence that could be used to prove what happened. It is important to keep it in a safe place. You may need it later to prove your version of events. Evidence might include:  
* video/audio recordings of the incident,   
* video/audio recordings of the incident,   
Line 86: Line 86:
* any other items or documents related to the incident.
* any other items or documents related to the incident.


==4.3 Go to the hospital or your doctor==
==Go to the hospital or your doctor==
If you have been injured, get medical help. Tell a doctor what happened. Describe all of your injuries in detail. Ask the doctor to take detailed notes of your complaints.  
If you have been injured, get medical help. Tell a doctor what happened. Describe all of your injuries in detail. Ask the doctor to take detailed notes of your complaints.  


Line 120: Line 120:
In complaints involving municipal forces, if you are not satisfied with the informal resolution or the investigator’s report, you can send a letter to the Office of the [[Police Complaints Commissioner (BC)]] asking for a review. The Commissioner <span class="noglossary">will</span> review the investigation and may <span class="noglossary">order</span> further investigation.
In complaints involving municipal forces, if you are not satisfied with the informal resolution or the investigator’s report, you can send a letter to the Office of the [[Police Complaints Commissioner (BC)]] asking for a review. The Commissioner <span class="noglossary">will</span> review the investigation and may <span class="noglossary">order</span> further investigation.


==How to start a lawsuit==
=How to start a lawsuit=


If you believe you have been harmed by a police officer that was acting improperly you have the option of starting a lawsuit.
If you believe you have been harmed by a police officer that was acting improperly you have the option of starting a lawsuit.


===Choosing whether or not to sue===
==Choosing whether or not to sue==
There are no straightforward lawsuits against the police, and success is never guaranteed. Lawsuits may take months or even years to reach a conclusion. You can expect the police to be represented by lawyers who will vigorously defend the case. Some lawsuits settle before trial, but these are rare and exceptional cases.  
There are no straightforward lawsuits against the police, and success is never guaranteed. Lawsuits may take months or even years to reach a conclusion. You can expect the police to be represented by lawyers who will vigorously defend the case. Some lawsuits settle before trial, but these are rare and exceptional cases.  


Line 131: Line 131:
You should be aware that a lawsuit is a public process. The documents you file to commence the lawsuit will be available to anyone who searches the court registry. Other documents filed in the course of the lawsuit will normally be available to the public as well. The trial is open to the public, and the judge's decision or jury's verdict will be made public. Lawsuits against the police sometimes attract the attention of media.  
You should be aware that a lawsuit is a public process. The documents you file to commence the lawsuit will be available to anyone who searches the court registry. Other documents filed in the course of the lawsuit will normally be available to the public as well. The trial is open to the public, and the judge's decision or jury's verdict will be made public. Lawsuits against the police sometimes attract the attention of media.  


===How to commence your lawsuit===
==How to commence your lawsuit==
You can sue in one of two courts: BC Provincial Court's "Small Claims Court" or BC Supreme Court. In either court, the only possible outcome is an award of money.  
You can sue in one of two courts: BC Provincial Court's "Small Claims Court" or BC Supreme Court. In either court, the only possible outcome is an award of money.  


Line 138: Line 138:
For more information on the choice of courts and the process for starting a lawsuit, see the chapter on [[I Need to Take Someone to Court]].
For more information on the choice of courts and the process for starting a lawsuit, see the chapter on [[I Need to Take Someone to Court]].


===Naming and serving the defendant===
==Naming and serving the defendant==
====RCMP====
===RCMP===


The "defendant" means the person or agency you are suing. In cases involving the RCMP, the appropriate defendant is "Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of British Columbia (Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General)" (pursuant to BC Order in Council 762/201 dated December 11, 2015). While the RCMP provides policing services under contract for the Province of British Columbia, it is a federal policing agency. Typically, a lawyer from the Federal Government (Department of Justice) will be assigned to defend the claim. Court documents such as the Notice of Civil Claim should be delivered by registered mail to:
The "defendant" means the person or agency you are suing. In cases involving the RCMP, the appropriate defendant is "Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of British Columbia (Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General)" (pursuant to BC Order in Council 762/201 dated December 11, 2015). While the RCMP provides policing services under contract for the Province of British Columbia, it is a federal policing agency. Typically, a lawyer from the Federal Government (Department of Justice) will be assigned to defend the claim. Court documents such as the Notice of Civil Claim should be delivered by registered mail to:
Line 148: Line 148:
:Victoria, BC V8W 9E2
:Victoria, BC V8W 9E2


====Municipal police forces====
===Municipal police forces===
In a municipality with its own police force, the appropriate defendant is the municipality itself (see [http://www.bclaws.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96367_01#section20 section 20 of the Police Act, RSBC 1996, c 367]. For example, if you wish to sue for damages caused by members of the Vancouver Police Department, you should name the "City of Vancouver" as a defendant. It is not proper to name the Vancouver Police Department because it is a department of the City, not itself a legal entity capable of being sued.  
In a municipality with its own police force, the appropriate defendant is the municipality itself (see [http://www.bclaws.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96367_01#section20 section 20 of the Police Act, RSBC 1996, c 367]. For example, if you wish to sue for damages caused by members of the Vancouver Police Department, you should name the "City of Vancouver" as a defendant. It is not proper to name the Vancouver Police Department because it is a department of the City, not itself a legal entity capable of being sued.  


Line 160: Line 160:
You should not name individual officers as defendants except in the most serious cases of misconduct. Officers are not personally liable for their conduct on the job except in the most extreme cases. That said, there may be advantages to naming individual officers as defendants at the beginning of the case to preserve your right to examine those officers prior to trial.   
You should not name individual officers as defendants except in the most serious cases of misconduct. Officers are not personally liable for their conduct on the job except in the most extreme cases. That said, there may be advantages to naming individual officers as defendants at the beginning of the case to preserve your right to examine those officers prior to trial.   


===What happens next?===
==What happens next?==
There are more procedural steps that must be followed in a lawsuit. See the section called [[I Need to Take Someone to Court — What's the Process?|I Need to Take Someone to Court]].
There are more procedural steps that must be followed in a lawsuit. See the section called [[I Need to Take Someone to Court — What's the Process?|I Need to Take Someone to Court]].


==How to file a human rights complaint==  
=How to file a human rights complaint=  
If you believe you have been discriminated against by a police officer you should consider filing a human rights complaint.  
If you believe you have been discriminated against by a police officer you should consider filing a human rights complaint.  


Line 172: Line 172:
For more information on filing a human rights complaint with either the BCHRT or the CHRC, please review the resources below.
For more information on filing a human rights complaint with either the BCHRT or the CHRC, please review the resources below.


==Where to get help==
=Where to get additional help=
See the [[Resource List for Legal Help for British Columbians|Resource List]] for a list of helpful resources. Your best bets are:
See the [[Resource List for Legal Help for British Columbians|Resource List]] for a list of helpful resources. Your best bets are:


Line 182: Line 182:
*[http://www.bchrc.net/ BC Human Rights Clinic]
*[http://www.bchrc.net/ BC Human Rights Clinic]
*[[Access Pro Bono]]
*[[Access Pro Bono]]
*[http://www.pivotlegal.org/ Pivot Legal Society]
*[[Lawyer Referral Service]]   
*[[Lawyer Referral Service]]   
*[[Private Bar Lawyers|Private bar lawyers]]
*[[Private Bar Lawyers|Private bar lawyers]]

Latest revision as of 22:22, 23 February 2022

This section provides an overview of your legal options if you have been harassed or assaulted by the police, or if you are the victim of other types of improper police behaviour.

What is improper police behaviour?[edit]

Examples of improper police behaviour include:

  • using excessive force in the course of an arrest or investigation,
  • arresting or detaining someone without reasonable grounds,
  • obtaining a search warrant using false information,
  • harassing or targeting members of the public for an improper reason, and
  • driving recklessly or dangerously.

What are my options?[edit]

You have at least three options. You could choose one or more of these:

  • a police complaint,
  • a lawsuit, and
  • a human rights complaint.

Each option is designed for a different purpose, and each leads to a different outcome. If possible, you should speak to a lawyer before deciding which option(s) to pursue. A lawyer can give you advice on which option(s) are most appropriate in your circumstances. In some cases, it might be appropriate to file a complaint or lawsuit in two or three of these forums. However, in cases where multiple proceedings have been commenced, the lawsuit will often be stalled pending the outcome of the police complaint or human rights complaint.

A police complaint refers to a complaint filed with the Office of the Police Complaint Commissioner (for cases involving a municipal police officer) or the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the RCMP. It may lead to an investigation of the officer’s conduct. You will be asked to give a statement. It might result in a recommendation for discipline of the officer(s) involved. It will not result in the payment of money for any injuries or harm you have suffered.
A lawsuit is filed with either the Provincial (Small Claims) Court or the Supreme Court of BC. There are special rules and processes that must be followed in either court. A lawsuit might lead to a settlement or judgment involving the payment of money.
A human rights complaint is filed with the BC or Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. These Tribunals are specialized to look into cases involving human rights abuses. A human rights complaint might lead to a settlement or judgment involving the payment of money.

When do I have to act?[edit]

This depends on which option(s) you choose to pursue. For example:

  • police complaints must normally be filed within 12 months of the incident,
  • lawsuits must normally be filed within 2 years of the incident, and
  • human rights complaints must normally be filed within 12 months of the incident.

It is best to get your complaint or lawsuit filed as soon as possible. The time limits described above are called "limitation periods."

NOTE: in cases involving municipal police departments there is a requirement to notify the municipality of the time, place and details of the incident within 2 months (see section 286 of the Local Government Act, RSBC 2015, c 1, and section 294(2) of the Vancouver Charter, SBC 1953, c 55). If you do not provide the municipality with this information your lawsuit may be dismissed on this basis, however, there are exceptions where a failure to provide notice will not be fatal to your claim. If you have missed this two-month notice period, you should provide the notice as soon as possible.

The following is a list of municipal police forces in British Columbia:

  • Abbotsford Police Department
  • Central Saanich Police
  • Delta Police Department
  • Nelson Police Department
  • New Westminster Police Service
  • Oak Bay Police Department
  • Port Moody Police Department
  • Saanich Police Department
  • Vancouver Police Department
  • Victoria/Esquimalt Police Department
  • West Vancouver Police Department

For example, the requirement to notify the City of Vancouver about an incident involving the Vancouver Police Department would be satisfied with the following letter:

---

City of Vancouver
453 West 12th Avenue
Vancouver, BC V5Y 1V4
Fax: (604) 873-7419
Attention: City Clerk
To Whom It May Concern:
Re: VPD Incident on [DATE]
I write pursuant to s. 294(2) of the Vancouver Charter, SBC 1953, c 55, to put the City of Vancouver on notice that I will be commencing a civil claim for damages against the City of Vancouver and members of the Vancouver Police Department. I was injured by members of the VPD on [DATE] at or near [PLACE].

How should I prove my case?[edit]

Write down what happened[edit]

Makes notes about the incident. These notes will help you recall details and may support your credibility down the road. You should include the following information:

  • date and time of the incident,
  • what were you doing prior to the incident,
  • who was involved, and who witnessed the incident,
  • the number and description of police officers involved,
  • what happened during the incident, in as much detail as possible,
  • who said what during the incident, and
  • what happened after the incident.

Preserve the evidence[edit]

There might be evidence that could be used to prove what happened. It is important to keep it in a safe place. You may need it later to prove your version of events. Evidence might include:

  • video/audio recordings of the incident,
  • photographs taken during the incident,
  • photographs of injuries taken after the incident,
  • badge numbers, business cards of officers involved,
  • statements from witnesses, and
  • any other items or documents related to the incident.

Go to the hospital or your doctor[edit]

If you have been injured, get medical help. Tell a doctor what happened. Describe all of your injuries in detail. Ask the doctor to take detailed notes of your complaints.

Follow the doctor’s advice. Fill any prescriptions right away. Return for a follow-up appointment as early as possible. Attend physiotherapy or specialist appointments if recommended. Get any recommended blood tests or imaging done right away.

Medical evidence is essential to prove your injuries following a police incident, if applicable.

How to file a police complaint[edit]

BC has two agencies that accept complaints about the police. One is for complaints against the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP). The other is for complaints against all other police forces, including municipal police forces. You do not need a lawyer to file a complaint, but a lawyer could help you prepare your complaint and follow it through to a conclusion.

The RCMP have responsibility for policing most of rural BC, and some urban centers including Surrey, North Vancouver, Richmond, Burnaby, Chilliwack, Kelowna, Nanaimo, and Prince George. A full list of RCMP detachments in BC is available on the RCMP's website.

If you have a complaint against one or more members of the RCMP you should file it with the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the RCMP ("CRCC"). Complaints can be filed online, or by telephone, fax, or regular mail. More information on how to file your complaint is found on the Commission's website.

Many municipalities have their own police force, as listed above. If you have a complaint against one or more members of a municipal police force, you should file it with BC’s Office of the Police Complaint Commissioner (“OPCC”). The OPCC also accepts complaints relating to the transit police and some tribal police forces, including the Kitasoo Xaixais Police Service and Stl'atl'imx Tribal Police. Complaints may focus on an officer’s conduct or more general policing policies. Complaints can be filed online or by fax or regular mail.

If you are unsure whether the incident involved one or more members of the RCMP or a municipal police department you should file your complaint with both the CRCC and the OPCC. It is always better to file your complaint with one of these two agencies rather than the police department itself. Filing your complaint with the CRCC or OPCC will ensure your complaint follows the formal investigation process.

Tipsandnotes.png
There is now an independent, civilian-led body that will conduct investigations into on- and off-duty police involved in incidents that result in death or serious harm. For more information see the website for the Independent Investigations Office of BC.

What happens next[edit]

Your complaint will be investigated by a police officer. In minor cases, the investigator will contact you and attempt to resolve the complaint informally, sometimes by arranging an apology or explaining what had happened. In more serious cases, or where you say that you would prefer not to do informal resolution, the investigator will investigate the incident in depth. You will be provided with a report of what happened.

You will not be awarded a sum of money as a result of your police complaint. At best, your complaint will be “substantiated”, or found to be warranted, and appropriate remedial action will be recommended, such as discipline or an amendment to policing policy.

Most complaints in British Columbia are not substantiated, which means the complainant’s version of events is not accepted, or the conduct complained about is determined to have been appropriate in the circumstances.

In complaints involving one or more members of the RCMP, if you are not satisfied with the informal resolution or the investigator’s report, you can submit a Request for Complaint Review to the Chair of the CRCC. The Chair may deny your request, order a further investigation or, in very serious cases, order a public hearing.

In complaints involving municipal forces, if you are not satisfied with the informal resolution or the investigator’s report, you can send a letter to the Office of the Police Complaints Commissioner (BC) asking for a review. The Commissioner will review the investigation and may order further investigation.

How to start a lawsuit[edit]

If you believe you have been harmed by a police officer that was acting improperly you have the option of starting a lawsuit.

Choosing whether or not to sue[edit]

There are no straightforward lawsuits against the police, and success is never guaranteed. Lawsuits may take months or even years to reach a conclusion. You can expect the police to be represented by lawyers who will vigorously defend the case. Some lawsuits settle before trial, but these are rare and exceptional cases.

Despite the challenges, a lawsuit is often the best option where you have suffered financial loss or injuries involving pain, disfigurement or disability as a result of police misconduct. It is often the only way to achieve compensation for those losses. You may achieve a sense of vindication or justice. A lawsuit will require the police to respond to the facts you present and the issues you raise. You will have the ability to compel production of the police file in relation to your case, and you will have the opportunity to examine the officers involved.

You should be aware that a lawsuit is a public process. The documents you file to commence the lawsuit will be available to anyone who searches the court registry. Other documents filed in the course of the lawsuit will normally be available to the public as well. The trial is open to the public, and the judge's decision or jury's verdict will be made public. Lawsuits against the police sometimes attract the attention of media.

How to commence your lawsuit[edit]

You can sue in one of two courts: BC Provincial Court's "Small Claims Court" or BC Supreme Court. In either court, the only possible outcome is an award of money.

In brief, Small Claims Court is appropriate for claims up to $35,000, while the Supreme Court has no limit on the value of claims. Small Claims Court is a simpler, quicker process, and you might resolve your claim in approximately 12 months. The Supreme Court process is more complicated, and a resolution might take 24 months or longer.

For more information on the choice of courts and the process for starting a lawsuit, see the chapter on I Need to Take Someone to Court.

Naming and serving the defendant[edit]

RCMP[edit]

The "defendant" means the person or agency you are suing. In cases involving the RCMP, the appropriate defendant is "Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of British Columbia (Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General)" (pursuant to BC Order in Council 762/201 dated December 11, 2015). While the RCMP provides policing services under contract for the Province of British Columbia, it is a federal policing agency. Typically, a lawyer from the Federal Government (Department of Justice) will be assigned to defend the claim. Court documents such as the Notice of Civil Claim should be delivered by registered mail to:

Her Majesty the Queen in Right of the Province of BC
Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General
PO Box 9010 Stn Prov Govt
Victoria, BC V8W 9E2

Municipal police forces[edit]

In a municipality with its own police force, the appropriate defendant is the municipality itself (see section 20 of the Police Act, RSBC 1996, c 367. For example, if you wish to sue for damages caused by members of the Vancouver Police Department, you should name the "City of Vancouver" as a defendant. It is not proper to name the Vancouver Police Department because it is a department of the City, not itself a legal entity capable of being sued.

For municipal police departments, court documents should be delivered to the municipality’s general delivery address. For example, in cases involving the Vancouver Police Department you would deliver your filed Notice of Civil Claim to the following address:

City of Vancouver
453 West 12th Ave.
Vancouver, B.C. V5Y 1V4
Attention: City Clerk

You should not name individual officers as defendants except in the most serious cases of misconduct. Officers are not personally liable for their conduct on the job except in the most extreme cases. That said, there may be advantages to naming individual officers as defendants at the beginning of the case to preserve your right to examine those officers prior to trial.

What happens next?[edit]

There are more procedural steps that must be followed in a lawsuit. See the section called I Need to Take Someone to Court.

How to file a human rights complaint[edit]

If you believe you have been discriminated against by a police officer you should consider filing a human rights complaint.

If the incident involved municipal police officers you must file your complaint with the BC Human Rights Tribunal ("BCHRT"). The BCHRT is an independent body responsible for dealing with complaints of discrimination pursuant to the BC Human Rights Code. The Human Rights Code prohibits a variety of discriminatory conduct including where a police officer treats a person differently or denies a service regularly available because of that person's race, colour, ancestry, place of origin, religion, marital status, family status, physical or mental disability, sex, sexual orientation or age of that person.

If the incident involved RCMP officer you must file your complaint with the Canadian Human Rights Commission (“CHRC”). The CHRC administers complaints under the Canadian Human Rights Act. The Act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, age, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, family status, disability and conviction for an offence for which a pardon has been granted or in respect of which a record suspension has been ordered.

For more information on filing a human rights complaint with either the BCHRT or the CHRC, please review the resources below.

Where to get additional help[edit]

See the Resource List for a list of helpful resources. Your best bets are:

This information applies to British Columbia, Canada. Last reviewed for legal accuracy by Neil Chantler, May, 2020.


Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 2.5 Canada Licence Legal Help for British Columbians © Cliff Thorstenson and Courthouse Libraries BC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 2.5 Canada Licence.