Anonymous

Difference between revisions of "Indigenous Families"

From Clicklaw Wikibooks
112 bytes removed ,  21:23, 20 June 2019
Line 17: Line 17:
In addition to the usual factors governing an award of child custody under s. 16 of the ''[[Divorce Act]]'', the court must also take into consideration a child's Aboriginal heritage when making a decision about custody. This is not expressly set out anywhere in the legislation, but past cases have decided that a child's Aboriginal heritage should be considered as part of the general ''best interests of the child'' test.
In addition to the usual factors governing an award of child custody under s. 16 of the ''[[Divorce Act]]'', the court must also take into consideration a child's Aboriginal heritage when making a decision about custody. This is not expressly set out anywhere in the legislation, but past cases have decided that a child's Aboriginal heritage should be considered as part of the general ''best interests of the child'' test.


This principle was established in British Columbia by ''[http://canlii.ca/t/1fqnq D.H. v. D.M.]'', [1999] 1 S.C.R. 761, a decision of the Supreme Court of Canada. In its decision, the court said that:
This principle was established by the Supreme Court of Canada in ''[http://canlii.ca/t/1fqnq D.H. v. D.M.]'', [1999] 1 S.C.R. 761. The court said that "the trial judge had given careful attention to the aboriginal ancestry of [the child], together with all the other factors relevant to [the child's] best interests, and that there was no error in his decision".


<blockquote>"... the trial judge had given careful attention to the aboriginal ancestry of [the child], together with all the other factors relevant to [the child's] best interests, and that there was no error in his decision ..."</blockquote>
In another case, ''[http://canlii.ca/t/51z8 Van de Perre v. Edwards]'', 2001 SCC 60, the Supreme Court of Canada commented that "racial identity is but one factor that may be considered in determining personal identity; the relevancy of this factor depends on the context. [...] All factors must be considered pragmatically, as different situations and different philosophies require an individual analysis on the basis of reliable evidence."
 
In another case, ''[http://canlii.ca/t/51z8 Van de Perre v. Edwards]'', 2001 SCC 60, the Supreme Court of Canada commented that:
 
<blockquote>"... racial identity is but one factor that may be considered in determining personal identity; the relevancy of this factor depends on the context. ... All factors must be considered pragmatically, as different situations and different philosophies require an individual analysis on the basis of reliable evidence."</blockquote>


===Guardianship under the ''Family Law Act''===
===Guardianship under the ''Family Law Act''===