Anonymous

Difference between revisions of "Contracts for Sale of Goods (11:III)"

From Clicklaw Wikibooks
Line 76: Line 76:
==== c) Implied Condition of Compliance with the Description: s 17 ====
==== c) Implied Condition of Compliance with the Description: s 17 ====


Under s 17, when goods are sold by description, there is an implied condition that they correspond to the description.  
Under s 17, when goods are sold by description, there is an implied '''condition''' that they correspond to the description.
:'''NOTE:''' '''Description''' refers to generic characteristics of a good and does not include words of praise about the good.


Most sales will be sales by description. The notable exception is where a buyer makes it clear that they are buying a particular item on the basis of its qualities known, independent of any representations by the seller. Generally, where a buyer purchases a product because of a vendor’s representations about its features (which may have been offered either gratuitously or in response to the buyer’s questions), this will be a sale by description, with the vendor’s representations forming part of the description. Catalogue purchases and purchases of products sealed in containers by the manufacturer are also sales by description.  
Most sales will be sales by description. The notable exception is where a buyer makes it clear that they are buying a particular item on the basis of its qualities known, independent of any representations by the seller. Generally, where a buyer purchases a product because of a vendor’s representations about its features (which may have been offered either gratuitously or in response to the buyer’s questions), this will be a sale by description, with the vendor’s representations forming part of the description. Catalogue purchases, online shopping, and purchases of products sealed in containers by the manufacturer are also sales by description.


'''NOTE:''' Specific (as opposed to unascertained) goods are goods that, at the time the contract is made, are agreed to be the only goods whose transfer will satisfy the contract. For example, in a sale of a new chair, if the parties agree that a specific chair is to be the  subject matter of the contract, the sale has been of specific goods. So, if the seller attempts to deliver a different chair, which is  identical in every way, except that it is not the actual chair agreed upon, the seller has breached the contract. Unascertained goods are goods that are agreed to be the subject matter of the contract at a point in time after the contract is made. For example, in the sale of a new chair, if the parties agree only on a specific type of chair, but do not specifically single out any individual chair, the sale has been of unascertained goods.  
If a sale is made by description and by sample, it is not enough that the bulk of the goods correspond with the sample; the delivered goods must also correspond with the description by which they were sold (s 17(2)).


Although s 17 cannot be excluded in retail sales of new goods, it may be excluded in private or commercial sales, subject to the ''contra proferentum'' rule. The ''contra proferentum'' rule states that a contract, if ambiguous, is construed as against the party who wrote it. Where a standard form contract is used, it is construed as against the party who offered it.  
:'''NOTE:''' '''Specific goods''' (as opposed to unascertained goods) are goods that, at the time the contract is made, are agreed to be the only goods whose transfer will satisfy the contract. For example, in a sale of a new chair, if the parties agree that a ''specific'' chair is to be the subject matter of the contract, the sale has been of specific goods. So, if the seller attempts to deliver a different chair, which is identical in every way, except that it is not the actual chair agreed upon, the seller has breached the contract. '''Unascertained goods''' are goods that are agreed to be the subject matter of the contract at a point in time after the contract is made. For example, in the sale of a new chair, if the parties agree only on a specific type of chair, but do not specifically single out any individual chair, the sale has been of unascertained goods.


A sale by description may also raise s 18(b) issues (see [[{{PAGENAME}}#e) Implied Condition of Merchantable Quality: s 18(b) | Section III.C.1.e: Implied Condition of Merchantable Quality]]).
Although s 17 cannot be excluded in retail sales of new goods, it may be excluded in private or commercial sales, subject to the ''contra proferentum'' rule. The ''contra proferentum'' rule states that a contract, if ambiguous, is construed as against the party who wrote it. Where a standard form contract (a “take it or leave it” contract that is drafted entirely by one party without any negotiations with the other party) is used, it is construed as against the party who offered it (usually the seller).
 
A sale by description may also raise s 18(b) issues (see [[{{PAGENAME}}#e) Implied Condition of Merchantable Quality: s 18(b) | e) Implied Condition of Merchantable Quality: s 18(b)]] below).


==== d) Implied Condition of Fitness for Buyer’s Purpose: s 18(a) ====  
==== d) Implied Condition of Fitness for Buyer’s Purpose: s 18(a) ====  
5,109

edits