2,734
edits
Difference between revisions of "Responding to a Small Claim (20:VI)"
From Clicklaw Wikibooks
Responding to a Small Claim (20:VI) (view source)
Revision as of 22:33, 22 November 2022
, 22:33, 22 November 2022→5. Counterclaim
| Line 41: | Line 41: | ||
=== 5. Counterclaim === | === 5. Counterclaim === | ||
If the defendant wants the court to order something other than a dismissal of the claimant’s claim, the defendant will need a counterclaim. A counterclaim means that, in addition to the defendant disputing the claim, the defendant seeks to sue the claimant. A defendant may file a counterclaim whether they agree or disagree with all or a part of the claim (''SCR'', Rule 4(1)). Counterclaims are claims filed by the defendant against the applicant; they are generally based on the same underlying facts as the applicant’s claim. A defendant who wishes to counterclaim should review | If the defendant wants the court to order something other than a dismissal of the claimant’s claim, the defendant will need a counterclaim. A counterclaim means that, in addition to the defendant disputing the claim, the defendant seeks to sue the claimant. A defendant may file a counterclaim whether they agree or disagree with all or a part of the claim (''SCR'', Rule 4(1)). Counterclaims are claims filed by the defendant against the applicant; they are generally based on the same underlying facts as the applicant’s claim. A defendant who wishes to counterclaim should review Section III: Do You Have a Claim?''' and [[Choosing_the_Proper_Forum_for_Small_Claims_(20:IV)|Section IV: Choosing the Proper Forum]]. A counterclaim is essentially a '''Notice of Claim but in a different form. A counterclaim must have a legal basis; there are penalties for proceeding to trial if there is no reasonable basis for success (''SCR'', Rule 20(5)). | ||
Although a defendant can start a separate claim either in Small Claims Court or another forum instead of counterclaiming, if the parties and witnesses are the same and the claim falls within the Small Claims Court jurisdiction, it is preferable that the defendant file a counterclaim so that both matters are heard together. If the defendant has commenced an action in a different forum, this should be mentioned in the Reply (see https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/law-crime-and-justice/courthouse-services/court-files-records/court-forms/small-claims/scl002.pdf) | Although a defendant can start a separate claim either in Small Claims Court or another forum instead of counterclaiming, if the parties and witnesses are the same and the claim falls within the Small Claims Court jurisdiction, it is preferable that the defendant file a counterclaim so that both matters are heard together. If the defendant has commenced an action in a different forum, this should be mentioned in the Reply (see https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/law-crime-and-justice/courthouse-services/court-files-records/court-forms/small-claims/scl002.pdf) | ||
